Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and the law governing commercial truck accidents is highly nuanced, so any potential claim should be evaluated individually based on its specific facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Lin McCraw, founder of McCraw Law Group, has represented injured Texans for more than three decades, with truck accident cases as a primary practice area. Board-certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization since 2006, he built a firm whose North Texas truck accident lawyers regularly review the safety records behind serious crashes.
Recent figures from coordinated roadside enforcement operations in the Dallas-Fort Worth area show why that work matters. According to data compiled by the North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG) and reported by The Dallas Morning News, an average of 53% of commercial vehicles inspected during 28 multi-agency operations between April 2021 and July 2026 were placed out of service for safety violations.
That number deserves careful reading. This article explains what the findings do and do not show, the most common violations inspectors uncover, how those defects can contribute to crashes, who is responsible for inspections and maintenance, and how safety violations may factor into liability after a truck accident in Texas.
What Did the Recent North Texas Truck Inspections Find?
The recent North Texas truck inspections found that more than half of the commercial vehicles examined during coordinated enforcement operations had violations serious enough to take them off the road.
Per NCTCOG data presented to the Regional Transportation Council and reported by The Dallas Morning News, the operations produced these results:
- 1,205 inspections across 28 multi-jurisdictional roadside operations
- 4,066 violations documented
- 505 citations issued
- 590 vehicles placed out of service
- An average out-of-service rate of 53%, compared with roughly 24% statewide and 23% nationally, according to the council
The data also showed out-of-service rates of 50% or higher in these coordinated operations since 2023. Officials pointed to poorly performed driver pre-trip inspections and inadequate maintenance by motor carriers and vehicle owners as contributing factors.
Why the 53% Figure Does Not Describe Every Truck in North Texas
The 53% figure is an average from specific enforcement operations, not a measure of all commercial trucks operating on North Texas roads. The data reflect only the vehicles inspected during those 28 coordinated events, and results from targeted enforcement may differ from what a broader sample of trucks would show.
Even with that context, regional officials described the out-of-service rate from these operations as unusually high. The gap between the region's operations average and the statewide and national figures suggests that safety problems among inspected trucks in the region warrant attention from drivers, carriers, and local leaders alike.
What Does It Mean When a Truck Is Placed Out of Service?
A truck placed out of service has a violation serious enough that it may not legally operate until the problem is corrected. Inspectors rely on the North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria, maintained by the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA), to identify conditions that pose an imminent hazard.
Out-of-service orders work in the following ways:
- According to CVSA, a vehicle with an out-of-service violation cannot be operated until those violations have been repaired
- Under 49 CFR 396.9, no motor carrier may require or permit anyone to operate a vehicle declared out of service, and no person may operate it, until the required repairs are completed
- Drivers can also be placed out of service for problems such as hours-of-service violations
What Are the Most Common Commercial Truck Safety Violations?
The most common commercial truck safety violations in the North Texas operations involved brakes, tires, and cargo securement, in that order, according to the official who presented the findings. Among driver violations, hours-of-service violations led the list, followed by operating without a medical card. Federal rules govern each category, and Texas has adopted most of them, with certain exceptions, through 37 Texas Administrative Code §4.11.
Brake System Violations
- Brake violations were the leading cause of vehicle out-of-service orders in the regional data
- Federal brake standards appear in 49 CFR Part 393, Subpart C, and 49 CFR 393.48 requires a truck's brakes to be capable of operating at all times
- Out-of-adjustment brakes, worn linings, air leaks, and damaged hoses can all reduce a loaded truck's ability to slow or stop
Tire Violations
- Tire violations ranked second among vehicle defects
- Under 49 CFR 393.75, trucks may not operate on tires with defects such as exposed ply or belt material, tread or sidewall separation, or audible leaks
- Steering axle tires must also have at least 4/32 of an inch of tread depth, while other tires require at least 2/32 of an inch
Improper Cargo Securement
- Cargo securement violations were the third most common vehicle defect
- Federal rules at 49 CFR 393.100 through 393.136 require cargo to be secured so it cannot leak, spill, blow off, or fall from the vehicle, or shift in a way that affects its stability
- 49 CFR 392.9 also requires drivers to inspect cargo and securement devices within the first 50 miles of a trip and periodically afterward
Driver Violations: Hours of Service and Medical Certification
- Hours-of-service violations were the most frequent reason drivers were placed out of service, followed by missing medical certification
- 49 CFR Part 395 limits how long drivers may drive and remain on duty, including an 11-hour driving limit for interstate property-carrying drivers; Texas applies somewhat different limits to many intrastate drivers
- Separately, 49 CFR 391.41 generally requires commercial drivers to be medically certified as physically qualified to drive
How Can Truck Safety Violations Contribute to Serious Accidents?
Truck safety violations can contribute to serious accidents by reducing a driver's ability to stop, steer, or maintain control of a load. Because loaded tractor-trailers weigh many times more than passenger vehicles, a mechanical problem that seems minor during an inspection may have severe consequences in traffic.
Federal research highlights the role of brakes in particular:
Each type of violation carries its own crash risks:
- Brake defects can lengthen stopping distances and contribute to rear-end collisions
- Tire failures can lead to a sudden loss of control or leave debris in traffic lanes
- Unsecured or shifting cargo can destabilize a trailer or spill onto the roadway
- Driver fatigue from hours-of-service violations may slow reaction times and impair judgment
- According to the U.S. Department of Transportation’s 2016 Comprehensive Truck Size and Weight Limits Study, trucks heavier than 80,000 pounds had higher overall out-of-service rates and 18% higher brake violation rates than trucks at or below that weight.
- A 2016 Insurance Institute for Highway Safety study found that trucks with any out-of-service violation were 362% more likely to be involved in a crash.
Officials also shared a local example:
- As reported by The Dallas Morning News, the presenting official described two serious commercial vehicle fatalities in Allen within one week several years ago
- One vehicle involved reportedly had both its driver and vehicle listed as out of service, along with a fraudulent inspection certificate
Who Is Responsible for Commercial Truck Inspections and Maintenance?
Motor carriers and truck drivers share responsibility for commercial truck inspections and maintenance under the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations. Texas incorporates most of those regulations by reference through 37 Texas Administrative Code §4.11, adopted under Texas Transportation Code Chapter 644, so many of the same standards apply to trucks operating within the state.
Trucking companies carry the broadest maintenance obligations. Key federal requirements include:
- Systematically inspecting, repairing, and maintaining every vehicle under the carrier's control, keeping parts in safe and proper operating condition at all times (49 CFR 396.3)
- Keeping maintenance records for each vehicle for one year and for six months after the vehicle leaves the carrier's control (49 CFR 396.3(c))
- Ensuring each vehicle passes a periodic inspection at least once every 12 months (49 CFR 396.17)
- Repairing safety defects reported by drivers before the vehicle operates again (49 CFR 396.11)
Drivers have their own inspection duties before and during each trip.
Under 49 CFR 392.7, a driver may not operate a commercial vehicle unless satisfied that parts such as the service brakes, steering, lights, tires, and coupling devices are in good working order. 49 CFR 396.13 also requires drivers to review the last vehicle inspection report before driving.
At the end of each workday, 49 CFR 396.11 generally requires drivers to report defects they find that could affect safe operation. These duties are directly connected to the regional findings, as officials cited poor pre-trip inspections and inadequate maintenance as contributing to the high out-of-service rate.
How Can Safety Violations Affect Liability After a Truck Accident in Texas?
Safety violations can be important evidence in a Texas truck accident claim, but a violation does not automatically establish liability. An injured person generally must still show that a party was negligent and that the negligence caused the injuries. How a violation affects any particular claim depends on the facts, the available evidence, and how Texas courts apply the law.
Negligence and Negligence Per Se
In some circumstances, Texas courts may treat the violation of a safety statute or regulation as negligence per se.
Whether the doctrine applies is a fact-specific legal question. The Texas Supreme Court discussed the factors courts weigh in Perry v. S.N., 973 S.W.2d 301 (Tex. 1998), and violations that do not qualify may still serve as evidence of ordinary negligence.
Trucking Company Liability
A trucking company may be held responsible for an employee driver's negligence under the doctrine of respondeat superior.
A company may also face separate claims based on its own conduct, such as negligent maintenance or negligent entrustment. Inspection reports, maintenance files, driver qualification files, and electronic logging data can help show whether a carrier followed the rules.
Some of those records are kept for limited periods. For example, 49 CFR 396.11 requires carriers to retain driver vehicle inspection reports for three months, so prompt steps to preserve evidence may matter after a crash.
Texas Trial Rules for Commercial Vehicle Cases
In 2021, Texas added Subchapter B to Chapter 72 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, which changed how many commercial vehicle crash lawsuits are tried.
On a defendant's motion, the court must divide the trial into two phases, and the law limits when evidence of regulatory violations may be introduced in the first phase. These rules add complexity to the presentation of safety violations in court.
Shared Fault and Filing Deadlines
Texas follows a proportionate responsibility system under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 33. Their percentage of responsibility reduces a claimant's recovery, and a claimant found more than 50% responsible may not recover damages.
Personal injury lawsuits must also generally be filed within two years under Section 16.003, though exceptions may apply.
Holding carriers accountable when poor maintenance injures people is also a policy fight. McCraw Law Group founder Lin McCraw, a past president of the Texas Trial Lawyers Association (TTLA), and Partner and Managing Attorney Charlie Ginn, TTLA’s Vice President of Legislative Affairs, have worked in Austin to protect injured Texans’ access to the courts and ensure negligent trucking companies can be held fully accountable.
Why Are Officials Concerned About Commercial Vehicle Enforcement in DFW?
Officials are concerned that the Dallas-Fort Worth region lacks sufficient commercial vehicle enforcement units or certified inspectors.
The concerns raised include the following:
- According to The Dallas Morning News, the presenting official told the Regional Transportation Council that some police departments have cut commercial vehicle enforcement staffing from several certified officers to one or two, while others have eliminated their programs entirely.
- Fewer inspectors may mean fewer chances to catch defects before a truck is involved in a crash.
- NCTCOG has long supported regional enforcement through its Commercial Vehicle Enforcement program, which focuses on reducing crashes involving overloaded and unsafe trucks.
- For people hurt in a crash, reduced enforcement can make an independent investigation of the truck and carrier especially important.
- The decline is not limited to North Texas. A CBS News investigation found that roadside truck safety inspections in Texas have dropped 27% since 2016.
Speak With a Truck Accident Lawyer in North Texas Today
Truck safety violations are more than numbers in a regional report. When a defective brake, worn tire, or unsecured load contributes to a crash, the consequences for a family can be life-changing. McCraw Law Group's attorneys know how to examine the inspection records, maintenance files, and federal compliance documents behind a commercial truck accident.
Partner and Managing Attorney Charlie Ginn is board certified in Personal Injury Trial Law, a member of the Academy of Truck Accident Attorneys and the American Board of Trial Advocates, and has presented to the Texas Trial Lawyers Association on auditing trip operational documents for FMCSA-regulated vehicles. He works alongside Litigation Director Bryce Hopson and a trial team that has recovered compensation in serious 18-wheeler cases across Texas.
If you were injured in a crash involving a commercial truck, our team offers free consultations and handles injury cases on a contingency-fee basis, so you pay no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you. With offices in McKinney, Frisco, Denton, Wylie, Sulphur Springs, and Amarillo, McCraw Law Group is ready to review your case. Call (972) 945-1173 to speak with a truck accident lawyer in North Texas.
Sources